Our verdict
- Our top pick in Fantastic grip level
Pros
- Remarkably supportive
- Fantastic grip level
- Pillow-like plushness
- Zero break-in
- Run-able flexibility
- Lightweight
- Warm in wintry conditions
- Above-average stability
Cons
- Questionable waterproofing
- Subpar breathability
- Its lugs get caked with mud easily
Audience verdict
Comparison
The most similar hiking boots compared
+ + Add a shoe | + + Add a shoe | + + Add a shoe | + + Add a shoe | + + Add a shoe | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audience score | |||||
| Best price | |||||
| Ranking | |||||
| Popularity | |||||
| # of colorways |
Who should buy the Cozy with a catch
The Cozy with a catch is a tough mid-top that promotes traversal agility. Buy it if:
- You're drawn to hiking boots that give wobbly ankles a stable hold.
- You often find yourself hiking in the cold.
- The areas you hike in have cambered parts where extra braking power is most welcome.
Its lugs get caked with mud easily
If you want something that grants excellent water protection without breathability issues, the Fairbanks Mid from Columbia is a great alternative. And if you're looking for a pair that sheds mud and debris as you go, the KEEN Pyrenees is for you.
Stupendous in the support category
These shoes are so supportive there's noticeably less foot fatigue at the end of the long hike! And there was absolutely no hint of ankle wobbliness! A perfect 10 for the support, for sure.
Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof
We expected a good grip on these, but not a superb grip. On hard packed trails, on soft ground, even on somewhat rocky trails - these were super sticky.
Beware though, the lugs seem to be too close to each other. Mud gets stuck there and then it's goodbye grip!
Something with extraordinary comfort
There's no break-in period. These are super comfy straight out of the box. And the comfort level is just un-be-lie-va-ble!
And look at that tongue. When the terrain got super demanding, we had to tighten the laces. And we felt absolutely no lace bite - thanks to this pillow of the tongue. So padded and so comfy!
Nimble feet in the Cozy with a catch
We just adore the featured kick's combination of lightness and flexibility. We were even able to actually run in these properly. They are flexible enough which is great.
that give wobbly ankles a stable hold
This is not a waterproof shoe. The water got in too easily, even when we were just hiking over some wet grass. Too bad.
Cozy with a catch
This shoe works better as a winter shoe. It keeps the heat in, which worked great for us. However, when we tested the shoe in somewhat warmer weather, our feet sweat. More than we liked.
Such a stable platform
The Cozy with a catch gives just the right amount of balance on rugged terrain. It's a perfect combination of comfort and stability.
